In today's interconnected world, the threat landscape for businesses has evolved significantly. One of the most insidious and challenging risks to manage is the insider threat. This article delves into what insider threats are, their implications, common threats, and effective risk mitigation strategies.

The integrity of supply chains is crucial for the smooth functioning of trade and commerce. However, organised criminal networks have increasingly infiltrated the supply chain, posing significant challenges for both businesses and law enforcement. Criminal organisations exploit weaknesses in supply chain processes, which they often learn by enlisting the aid of employees within supply chain businesses. These illicit operations not only disrupt legitimate trade but also lead to substantial financial losses and reputational damage for affected companies. This article explores the risk of insider threat, as well as strategic measures that fortify supply chains against such vulnerability.

Criminal organisations exploit weaknesses in supply chain processes

Defining insider threat

An insider threat refers to the risk posed by individuals within an organization who have access to sensitive information and systems. These individuals can be full-time employees, part-time workers, contractors, or even business partners. Insider threats can be intentional or unintentional, with malicious insiders seeking to cause harm for personal gain or ideological reasons, while unintentional insiders may inadvertently compromise security through negligence or lack of awareness.

Insiders may inadvertently compromise security through negligence or lack of awareness

Acknowledging the risk

It may be difficult to acknowledge that a trusted employee might collude with criminals. Many supply chain operations are close-knit and there is often a sense of site camaraderie that belies a risk of criminal activity. There are many reasons why an employee might fall prey to criminal elements, and it can be helpful to consider them. Employees can be approached by members of criminal organisations, who act as recruiters. Whereas a legitimate recruiter looks for skills and strengths, illegitimate recruiters look for weaknesses that they can use as leverage over a potential insider.

Their recruitment tools include blackmail, intimidation and dire financial need. They will coax and threaten until they achieve their ends but once an employee succumbs the trap is sprung. To an employee who is experiencing threats or blackmail, one small act, such as passing on information about a shipment, may seem like the path of least resistance. However, the criminals will then use that act to further blackmail the employee to commit further, and potentially more serious, criminal acts. Insiders often see little benefit from their involvement.

Defending against the risk

Although they may be directly involved in outright theft of goods, insiders are quite often most useful to criminal organisations as sources of information. Insiders have access to many sources of useful information, such as stockholding records, load and route plans, and even CCTV records. It is prudent to consider whether systemic access should be limited. Systemic access rights tend to proliferate over time to facilitate and speed the operation and the effect on security is often overlooked. Maintaining segregation between warehousing and transportation parts of the business is an important informational firebreak.

Another way to control the risk of insider collusion is to thoroughly vet prospective employees. Criminal organisations may strategically infiltrate supply chain operations, particularly those involved in the storage and transportation of high value goods. Managers are advised to be particularly vigilant at sites storing goods such as tobacco, alcohol or consumer electronics. Subcontracted agency workers are a notable risk. Such workers tend to move often between different operations in an area and their wide knowledge makes them particularly valuable targets for criminal organisations.

Communication as mitigation

As in many aspects of effective operational practice, strong leadership and effective communication are key to mitigating the risk of insider collusion. It is firstly important that managers get to know workers on a personal basis. An employee who is struggling financially for example might be at an elevated risk of exploitation by criminal organisations. Supporting vulnerable workers helps protect the business from the consequences of such exploitation.

Having an effective whistleblower policy is also important, but the effectiveness of such policies relies too on the relationship between managers and workers. Workers who do not trust managers to handle reports sensitively are unlikely to report concerns at all. Building trust happens when managers communicate honestly with workers about the dangers involved in succumbing to criminal recruitment. Criminals exploit workers through blackmail and intimidation to make them feel isolated and vulnerable. Businesses can counter this tactic by talking openly about the issue and offering workers understanding, protection and even amnesty for past misdeeds. Workers who feel trapped in a cycle of blackmail and criminal action may struggle to see a way out of the trap in which they find themselves. Businesses may break this cycle by effectively showing a worker a way out.

Workers who do not trust managers to handle reports sensitively are unlikely to report concerns at all

Summary

Insider threats pose a significant challenge to businesses, but with a comprehensive understanding of the risks and the adoption of effective mitigation strategies, organizations can protect themselves from these insidious threats. By fostering a positive security culture, educating employees, and implementing robust security measures, businesses can reduce the likelihood of insider threats and safeguard their operations.

-

If you would like further information, or have any comments, please email us, or take this opportunity to forward to any others who you may feel would be interested.